Frodo’s Rankings:
(*** = amended in a later episode)

  1. Pink Elephants on Parade (Dumbo): A+ for Pink Elephants
  2. When You Wish Upon A Star (Pinocchio): A for A Star
  3. Heigh Ho (Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs): A- for Mines
  4. I’ve Got No Strings (Pinocchio): A- for Applause
  5. Whistle While You Work (Snow White): B+ for Bouncy
  6. Casey, Jr. (Dumbo): B+ for Brief
  7. All the Cats Join In (Make Mine Music): B+ for Benny Good-man
  8. The Silly Song (Snow White): B for Band
  9. Give a Little Whistle (Pinocchio): B for “Brrrum”
  10. I’m Wishing (Snow White): B
    –         –        –          –          –           –
  11. Love is a Song (Bambi): B*** for Better than “One Song”
  12. Someday My Prince Will Come (Snow White): B- for Mush
  13. Looking for Romance (Bambi): B-*** for Curmudgeonly Surprising
  14. Hi-Diddle-Dee-Dee (Pinocchio): B- “For Me”
  15. Little Wooden Head (Pinocchio): C+ for Puppet
  16. Little April Shower (Bambi): C+ for Pretty Little Pitter Patter
  17. Baby Mine (Dumbo) : C for Sweet
  18. With a Smile and a Song (Snow White): C for Chipper
  19. Mexico (The Three Caballeros): C for Calming
  20. When I See an Elephant Fly (Dumbo): C- for Mostly Racist
    –         –        –          –          –           –
  21. Johnny Fedora and Alice Blue Bonnet (Make Mine Music): C- for Cork Pie Hat
  22. Casey (The Pride of Them All) (Make Mine Music): D+ for Dat Baseball Doe
  23. Saludos Amigos (Saludos Amigos): D for Disney Sells Out
  24. Bluddle-Uddle-Um-Dum (Snow White): D for Dirty
  25. Make Mine Music (Make Mine Music): D for Didn’t We Just Do This One?
  26. Let’s Sing a Gay Little Spring Song (Bambi): D- for Don’t
  27. Look Out for Mr. Stork (Dumbo): D- for Dumbo
  28. Two Silhouettes (Make Mine Music): D- for Dinah Shote
  29. The Song of The Roustabouts (Dumbo): F+ for Problematic
  30. Blue Bayou (Make Mine Music): F+ for Painfully Boring
    –         –        –          –          –           –
  31. One Song (Snow White): F for Forgettable
  32. The Clown Song (Dumbo): G for Greed


Amanda’s Rankings:

  • Snow White Songs (Movie Ranking 2)
  1. The Silly Song: 9/10 Poison Apples
  2. Heigh Ho: 8/10 Poison Apples*
  3. One Song: 6/10 Poison Apples*
  4. Whistle While You Work: 6/10 Poison Apples*
  5. Someday My Prince Will Come: 5/10 Poison Apples*
  6. I’m Wishing: 3/5 Poison Apples*
  7. With a Smile and a Song: 3/10 Poison Apples
  8. Bluddle-Uddle-Um-Dum: 3/10 Poison Apples

*In episodes 7 and 8, Amanda reordered her songs, so rankings do not necessarily match apple count.

  • Pinocchio Songs (MR 3)
  1. When You Wish Upon A Star: 9/10 Bow Ties
  2. Hi-Diddle-Dee-Dee: 7/10 Bow Ties
  3. Give a Little Whistle: 7/10 Bow Ties
  4. Little Wooden Head: 5/10 Bow Ties
  5. I’ve Got No Strings: 3/10 Bow Ties
  • Dumbo Songs (MR 4)
  1. Casey, Jr.: 8.5/10 Elephant Ears  *Amended in Episode 20
  2. Pink Elephants on Parade: 7/10 Flakey Elephant Ears
  3. Look Out for Mr. Stork: 6.5/10 Freed Circus Animals
  4. Baby Mine: 6/10 Elephant Ears
  5. The Clown Song: 3/10 Elephant Ears
  6. When I See an Elephant Fly: 3/10 Elephant Ears
  7. The Song of the Roustabouts: Ungraded
  • Bambi Songs (MR 1)
  1. Looking For Romance: 8.5 Thumping Bunny Rabbits
  2. Little April Shower: 7/10 Thumping Bunny Rabbits
  3. Love is a Song: 6/10 Thumping Bunny Rabbits
  4. Let’s Sing a Gay Little Spring Song: 6/10 Thumping Bunny Rabbits
  • Saludos Amigos
  1. Saludos Amigos: 6.5/10 Dancing Llamas
  • The Three Caballeros
  1. Mexico: 2/10 Bouncing Sombreros
  • Make Mine Music
  1. All the Cats Join In: 6/10 Music Notes
  2. Johnny Fedora and Alice Blue Bonnet: 4/10 Make Mine Musics
  3. Make Mine Music: 3/10 Making Musics
  4. Two Silhouettes: 2/10 Make Mine Musics
  5. Casey (The Pride of Them All): 2/10 Baseball Bats
  6. Blue Bayou: 2/10 Dying Egrets